The Old Bermuda Inn

November 7th, 2008

photo taken from weddingcottage.com

Located in the borough of Staten Island, New York the Mesereau family built this mansion in 1832. The beautiful inn now serves as a restaurant and wedding and party facility. The mansion has been extended but the original part of the mansion still remains in use. In 1860, Mr. Mesereau went off to fight in the Civil War. He left behind his wife Martha, who waited intently for the safe return of her loved one. She would look outside of her bedroom window day and night.

Martha kept vigil at the window watching out at the water looking for her husband’s ship. At night, she would leave a candle in the window so her husband could find his way home. One day, Martha received the news she had never wanted to hear. Her husband had been killed in battle and Martha could not accept this. Legend has it that Martha retreated to her room and died in there of a broken heart. Martha’s room is called the Somerset Room, and today is a beautiful dining area. This dining area is believed to be haunted by her spirit.

People have reported seeing Mary’s silhouette in the window, as well as a figure walking around in the front part of the inn. Workers at the restaurant have reported strange noises and locked doors opening on their own. There is an oil painting of Martha that hangs in the first floor hallway of the original part of the mansion. This portrait has been involved in paranormal activities. When construction for the mansion began, workers would hear noises from the original part of the mansion.

A few days into the construction, the portrait mysteriously went on fire. No one knows for sure how this happened since there was nothing that seemed to spark the fire. The burn marks can still be seen on the bottom of the painting. People believe that the noises and the fire was Martha trying to show her disapproval of the new renovations that were being made to the mansion. Real Hauntings investigated the inn, and experienced some very strange events.

Camera’s that were set up in Martha’s room would not work for some reason. Upon entering the hallway from the bedroom, the camera would then instantly work. Photos taken reveal only one orb, which would make sense since Martha is the only spirit that is believed to haunt the inn. EVP captured opening and closing of the closet door in Martha’s room, as well as a woman’s voice whispering “Listen.” One final strange event that the Old Bermuda Inn offers is that every night, one light on the chandelier hanging from the first floor highway will never shutoff, even if the power is cut.

(Source: Belanger, Jeff. Encyclopedia of Haunted Places. 2005.)

Related Posts

Chris Haunted Places



Our Sponsors





  1. jordana
    February 27th, 2009 at 17:40 | #1

    I Have been in the old bermuda inn for my cousins sweet sixteen and we were there intul 1:00 A.M and i did not have any experience =(

  2. September 14th, 2011 at 20:01 | #2

    local Locksmith provides 24/7 fast, reliable, professional Emergency Locksmith services at extremely competitive rates. At Vista Locksmith we stand behind our workmanship – 100% client satisfaction guaranteed. We have a fully equipped Mobile machine shop available 24 hours a day 7 days a week. Vista Locksmith services all locks and associated door hardware, including the brands we do not sell.

  3. Mikayla clark
    February 12th, 2012 at 22:55 | #3

    I went to the Bermuda inn and in the dinning hall on this ledge there r 3 pics me and my friends noticed 2 were the same butt one had the ladys husband with a white face & if u look at that pic long enough u see the mans eyes look at u

  1. No trackbacks yet.